Two items in the news/blogosphere over the last week caught my attention and triggered a thought in my mind.
The first was the news that a survey by Environics for TD Canada Trust found that 30 per cent of respondents don’t have enough cash to pay for basic living expenses. This was run as the headline in most papers, although interestingly 30% was inflated to “one-third” by most of them…
The second item was from the blogosphere, where Dan Tappin at MapleLeafParty.ca posted this interesting graph:

Now, one might imagine that the 30% of Canadians who can’t afford basic living expenses would all be members of the bottom 50% of incomes. But I don’t think that is true. Why? Partly because of material published in the first article I mentioned above:
12 per cent said they can’t afford to pay their bills every month, and the same proportion admitted they’re shopping beyond their means.
The same poll had 38 per cent of respondents saying they have no savings at all, and 54 per cent find it a struggle, if not impossible, to put money away.
Hmm. I have trouble believing that 76% of the bottom 50% of incomes (<$35,000 per person) in Canada don’t save anything. Therefore, some of the people “struggling” to get by must be in the top half of incomes.
Another factor could be Canadians’ high personal debt levels, which average almost 150 per cent of annual disposable income.
Hmm. So, if the average Canadian has that much personal debt, then a significant portion of income must be going to debt servicing. So when the survey says people can’t afford basics, how much of that is because they spent too much on a car, or a big TV, or an iPhone, when they really shouldn’t have?
I mean, look at it this way – if you buy an iPad 2 with all the bells and whistles, that can be up over $800. Which is 1% of your income if you make $80,000 per year. But are only people making over that high income buying iPads? No…
Part of the problem is that too many people can’t manage their money and don’t understand that they can’t have everything they want. It is a social problem. But the solution is not government intervention. It’s parents teaching their children the value of money. And people taking responsibility for themselves.